HitMyCredit
Sign in →

You switched to save money. Then this happened.

My electricity bill is higher after switching providers

The advertised rate looked cheaper. The real bill wasn't. Here's the gap between the two that most people don't find out about until it's too late.

Check my new plan

Advertised vs. actual

Why the rate you signed up for isn't the rate you paid

What the ad showed

A headline rate — sometimes the EFL's "average price at 1,000 kWh" — that assumes you hit a specific usage threshold every single cycle to unlock the advertised price or a bill credit.

What actually happened

Your first cycle on the new plan came in under (or over) that threshold, so the credit or discounted rate never applied — and your effective rate ended up higher than your old plan's, even though the sticker rate looked lower.

Don't forget the partial first cycle

Switching providers often means your first bill covers a short, prorated period — which can make the per-cycle dollar total look worse than it actually is on a per-day basis. Always compare effective ¢/kWh rate across at least two full billing cycles before deciding a switch didn't pay off.

Make the new plan actually work

Track usage against your new threshold

HitMyCredit connects to your Smart Meter and tracks your daily kWh against your new plan's credit threshold — so you actually get the rate you switched for.

Start Tracking Free →

Bill higher after switching — FAQ

Why is my bill higher after switching electricity providers in Texas?

The most common cause: the plan you switched to has a usage-based bill credit (often requiring 1,000+ kWh) that you didn’t hit on your first cycle, so you paid the full uncredited rate — which can be higher than what you were paying before, even though the advertised rate looked cheaper. A shorter-than-usual first billing cycle from the provider switch itself can also inflate the per-day cost comparison.

Do advertised electricity rates in Texas include bill credits?

Often the headline rate shown in marketing (and sometimes the EFL’s "average price") already assumes you hit the credit threshold every month. If you don’t, your actual effective rate is meaningfully higher than what was advertised — this is one of the most common sources of switching regret.

How long does it take for a new plan to show real savings?

Usually 2–3 full billing cycles, since the first cycle after a switch is often partial (prorated) and can distort the comparison. Compare your effective ¢/kWh rate — not just the total dollar amount — across at least two complete cycles before judging whether the switch worked out.

What should I check on my new provider’s bill?

Your actual energy rate (¢/kWh), whether there’s a credit threshold and whether you hit it, and the length of the billing cycle. Our free Bill Analyzer reads all of this from your uploaded bill automatically and tells you whether the plan is behaving the way it was advertised.